Jerry Barnett Debates Julie Bindel At Essex University

Jerry Barnett Debates Julie Bindel At Essex University

On 22 October 2014, Essex University held a debate on pornography at its Colchester campus.

To quote the university website:

Jerry Barnett made a fortune as an online distributor of pornography. He regularly appears on media as a libertarian activist.

Julie Bindel is a leading English feminist, columnist, and co-founder of Justice for Women.

Here is Barnett’s account, from his indispensable site, Sex & Censorship:

Those familiar with the state of anti-porn argument will know it’s pretty comparable with anti-climate change argument: very little in the way of evidence, but plenty in the way of noise, indignation, conspiracy theory and “it stands to reason”-type arguments.

The foundation of today’s anti-porn rhetoric was laid by Catharine Mackinnon and Andrea Dworkin (“the Macdworkinites”) in the 1980s, and the arguments appear not to have evolved greatly in the intervening decades; today’s anti-porn feminism lacks the flair and (evil) genius of the Macdworkinites. For this reason, it’s increasingly easy to demolish claims of harm caused by pornography; the problem is that the media is still largely in the sway of the “OMG what about the children?!” brigade. It’s for this reason that I founded Sex & Censorship: to present evidence-based argument against the combined religious/feminist weight of porn panic.

University debates are a rare opportunity to be heard equally in a fair environment (rather than the 90 seconds of shouting allowed by the news media), and I take every opportunity to participate in these (contact me if you’d like me to debate or speak at your university or college). I therefore seized yesterday’s opportunity to debate the radical feminist Julie Bindel with glee.

Things warmed up on the day before the debate, with the publication of an article in the student newspaper that managed to disparage both myself and Bindel at once, referring to her as a homophobe and transphobe, while I was simply branded a “multi-millionaire”. Sadly (for me), this claim wasn’t true, but even if it had been, I failed to see the relevance in this context: surely “sexual freedom advocate”, “free speech activist” or even just “blogger” would have been more useful.

So when I met Bindel on the train to Colchester, we were able to find some common cause, and jokingly speculate about which one of us might be more protested-against: her, the transphobe; or me, the spokesman for patriarchal oppression.

Keep reading…

Jerry Barnett Debates Julie Bindel At Essex University
Barnett vs. Bindel
 

One Response to "Jerry Barnett Debates Julie Bindel At Essex University"

  1. Pingback: Jerry Barnett Debates Julie Bindel At Essex University | Adult WIkiMedia

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.